[phenixbb] Is it possible to do Molecular Replacement for synthesized "small" molecule X-ray data?
a.perrakis at nki.nl
Tue Dec 8 12:41:34 PST 2009
What a nice molecule according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cucurbituril
Did you by any chance crystallize it as a salt? In the previous century,
this happened to me with a cyclodextrin complex that had a Br atom.
The Br was visible in the native patterson, and that had at the time
triggered my interest in 'ARP' that was soon after to become 'ARP/wARP'.
If there is a chance for a 'heavy' atom there, use it!
Looking at the molecule I would expect a cloud of solutions in MR, all
pretty good but every ~50 degrees
on gamma, given the cyclic molecule, if I got the structure right. So,
you would have no 'unique' solution.
However, putting any of the top solutions in 'ARP/wARP map improvement
by free atoms addition and deletion' should/could yield
a good map with 1.5 A data.
Apologies for the non-phenix shameless self-promoting plugin, but I
think you might find this actually useful.
On 8 Dec 2009, at 21:18, Randy J. Read wrote:
> Dear Yves,
> That's probably getting close to the limit of the ratio of the size
> of the
> molecule to the resolution, which is one of the main things
> whether molecular replacement will work. At 1.5A, you'd have to have a
> pretty accurate model of the structure as well (i.e. RMSD signficantly
> under 1A, at a guess). Another problem with molecular replacement
> for small
> molecules is that small molecule crystals tend to be tightly packed,
> makes things somewhat harder. Nonetheless, I've done test
> calculations in
> the past that show it can work.
> One thing you should watch out for: Phaser only accepts atoms that are
> given as ATOM records in a PDB file, so if you have HETATM records,
> atoms will be rejected.
> If you'd like to send the logfile from Phaser (preferably off-line), I
> could take a look at it.
> Randy Read
> On Dec 8 2009, Yves Wang wrote:
>> Hi PHENIX users,
>> We've got a synthesized molecule, called Cucurbituril, molecular
>> weight 1163 Da. We were able to grow crystals of cucurbituril with
>> one of its ligand. This crystal diffracted to 1.5A at our X-ray
>> The dilemma is that, at this resolution, we can't use small molecule
>> crystallography softwares to solve the structure (correct me if I'm
>> wrong, we need at least 1A resolution?), while macromolecular X-ray
>> softwares are really not designed for synthesized molecules.
>> We have collected diffraction data of this crystal with decent
>> So I'm wondering if there's any way we can put a known crystal
>> structure of cucurbituril and solve the structure of the
>> complex. We
>> have tried AutoMR but the solution is not very encouraging.
>> Any suggestion will be gratefully appreciated.
> phenixbb mailing list
> phenixbb at phenix-online.org
More information about the phenixbb